Tap to Trade in Gate Square, Win up to 50 GT & Merch!
Click the trading widget in Gate Square content, complete a transaction, and take home 50 GT, Position Experience Vouchers, or exclusive Spring Festival merchandise.
Click the registration link to join
https://www.gate.com/questionnaire/7401
Enter Gate Square daily and click any trading pair or trading card within the content to complete a transaction. The top 10 users by trading volume will win GT, Gate merchandise boxes, position experience vouchers, and more.
The top prize: 50 GT.
.
In contrast, the largest legal open music database, MusicBrainz, has only about 5 million entries, while the database established by Anna's Archive is a staggering 37 times larger.
Source: Anna’s Archive Anna’s Archive claims to have control over 99% of the metadata of 256 million tracks on Spotify, including 86 million key audio files of songs that are actually being listened to.
Data analysis also revealed a significant disparity in traffic within the Spotify platform. Out of 256 million tracks, over 70% of the songs have a popularity score of zero, meaning these songs are virtually ignored.
Statistics indicate that only about 210,000 songs (approximately 0.1% of the total catalog) have a popularity score above 50, and it is precisely this small number of tracks that account for the vast majority of listening activity. In other words, most of the music content on Spotify is rarely listened to, resembling a music graveyard.
Source: Anna’s Archive Anna’s Archive claims that over 70% of the songs on Spotify have a popularity score of zero, meaning that these songs are almost ignored.
Anna’s Archive states that they do not back up the content in the graveyard because storing these obscure files, which account for only 0.04% of listening activity, would require an additional 700 TB of storage space, and many of the contents are considered to be low-quality music generated by AI.
Anna's Archive argues that there is no piracy, and a full release could affect musicians' income.
Anna's Archive released a detailed analysis report along with the data, showing significant clustering of track lengths at 2 minutes, 3 minutes, and 4 minutes, which are commonly found lengths for popular songs.
In addition, since 2015, the number of album releases has seen exponential explosive growth, with over 10 million albums marked in 2023 alone, likely driven by the popularity of AI-generated music and automated upload tools.
Source: Anna’s Archive Anna’s Archive claims that since 2015, the number of album releases on Spotify has grown exponentially, with over 10 million albums tagged in 2023 alone.
Anna's Archive argues in the article that their reason for scraping Spotify data is to establish a music preservation archive, and claims that existing music preservation efforts are too focused on popular artists and high-quality formats (such as lossless FLAC), which puts obscure music at risk of disappearing when the platform changes policies or shuts down.
But regardless of how Anna's Archive tries to argue, their actions are essentially piracy!
Spotify pays creators a royalty fee of about $0.003 to $0.005 per stream. According to Dittomusic's calculator, 1,000,000 streams can bring approximately $4,370 in revenue to creators.
But if everything is uploaded as seed files and made available for free download, it will prevent creators from earning a single cent, regressing human copyright back to the era of rampant piracy.
Hacker News users speculate that the real purpose is to sell it to AI companies for training.
This data leak has also sparked heated discussions on the technology forum Hacker News. Some netizens speculate that Anna's Archive may have provided enterprise-level access services for its pirated book database for as much as tens of thousands of dollars, meaning selling bulk data to AI companies for training models.
Extended reading: Google AI summary hitting a snag? The EU launches an antitrust investigation, and if violations are found, it could lead to sky-high fines.
Anna's Archive may be sued, but it's very difficult to completely take down seed uploads.
The rampant Anna's Archive organization has actually been targeted by multiple governments.
According to foreign media Decrypt, since 2012, Google has removed 749 million URLs related to Anna's Archive from search results based on copyright complaints, accounting for 5% of all Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) takedown requests it has received.
In December 2024, the High Court of England approved a blocking order against Anna's Archive; in July 2025, Belgium also issued a blocking order, with a maximum fine of 500,000 euros for violators; Germany also blocked the main domain of the website in October 2025.
External predictions suggest that Spotify may take legal action against Anna’s Archive, but since the data is being distributed through a decentralized P2P network, spread across thousands of nodes worldwide, no single entity can completely shut it down.
This is precisely the core characteristic of seed technology. Once a file is leaked, it is almost an impossible task to completely take it down. This copyright war in the digital age is likely to enter a new, more chaotic phase.